Well... I started playing through it again this weekend on a whim. I'd just worked an 18.5 hour day (after a week of 12 hour days, after a week of 10 hour days) and I was pretty fried. I wanted something new, or something nostalgically old. So I turned my room upside down looking for the expansion.

I have to say... I'm impressed. For all my lobbying against it years ago, I'm pleased to see I was dead wrong.
First of all, I like the weapons set. They increase my ammo capacity and damage output of course, and add to the whole resource management thing that Quake centers around. But they also WORK well and look good. Though the art replacement and programming are super simple -- often just a damage increase and a skin swap -- it works wonders on my psyche to pull out my lava nailgun (of which I've usually collected 200) and just unload them on a swarm of fiends and hell knights. It's not just that they're powerful, it's that they burn.

And the cluster grenades and rockets seem to work well. The rockets cover a wide spread, and the grenades scatter over a wide area. I suspect the grenades would suck in multiplayer, but they work rather well against monsters (except the dang fiends).
The level design is quite nice, and memorable I might add. The first few levels are burned into my memory and I still remember sections of them after all these years. I sure like some of them better than the original quake levels.


I wasn't impressed with the start level though. All that professional work and yet the place you start looks... awkward. O_o The rest of start looks nice though.
I've only gotten a few levels down memory lane (level 4 or 6 or so and I died right at the end, lol), but I think I'm going to make time to charge through the rest, guns-a-blaz'n. I did this with original Quake a few years back (playing through with a fresh outlook and no cheats) and loved it, and I suspect I'll feel the same way with this pack too.
I'm glad I gave the pack a second chance. Here's to nostalgia vindicated.

(and btw, playing it in Darkplaces FTW
